Drama Review: Andrew Farkas Reads Jesi Bender’s Play Crux

So, you say you want a revolution. Well, you know there are a lot of questions to answer when you decide on this course of action, perhaps the most important being whether you’ll go with a violent or a nonviolent protest. If you choose violence, you can certainly break your opponents either by annihilating their forces, or by chipping away at them over the years. The problem is, after you’ve gone all in on death and destruction, you are left to wonder, or the civilians are left to wonder, which faction is actually worse. If the tally sheet shows the game’s a tie, even, then has your revolution been successful? Sure, the old guard is gone, but how much better are you? Napoleon, who obviously had no problem with warfare, once appeared to believe in a great many high-minded ideals, but then he won and went about becoming, right, Napoleon. The more moral stance would have to be nonviolence in that case. The problem there is how do you bring about change? Even if a great many citizens join your side, the government isn’t just going to give up. In fact, if your background is blemished, they will use whatever they can against you. So, what can be done?

Bobby Sands, the protagonist of Jesi Bender’s Crux and actual member of the Irish Republican Army (IRA), tries both styles of protest. Before Bender’s play begins, Sands planned the Balmoral Furniture Company bombing and took part in a firefight with the Royal Ulster Constabulary. Once in HM Maze Prison (called the H-Blocks throughout the play), though, he shifts gears to nonviolent via the blanket protest (where the convicts refuse to wear prison uniforms, instead draping themselves in blankets), the dirty protest (where the prisoners refuse to wash and smear feces all over the walls of their cells), and then, finally, the focus of Crux, the hunger strike.

Zooming in on a character who’s slowly dying of starvation perhaps sounds like a curious choice, since it’s not exactly rife with action, though in my opinion Bender already shows the first level of audacity needed for a revolution. Our world now is full of stridently loud people who all seem to be demanding that everyone should look at them all the damn time; Sands, on the other hand, wants you to think about why a person would put themselves through such terrible pain, knowing full well they might die: “Someone has to say no […]. Someone has to be right.” Anyway, don’t worry, Bobby isn’t by himself long, since the next level of audacity Bender displays is the magical realist importing of other dissidents into Sands’ prison cell. Most of them, as they say themselves, are dead (Haia Lifşiț, Jatindra Nath Das, Lucy Parsons, Marion Wallace-Dunlop), one is alive (Bayard Rustin), but all of them are ready to engage in a Socratic-style dialogue on effective protests. From there you might expect a division between those who believe in nonviolent means (Rustin, for instance) and those who believe in violent means (Parsons, for instance), which we do get. However, a third stance arises early in the work that exemplifies the most audacity of all: what is the purpose of dissent? Is it actually to bring about change? Or, is it much more egocentric than that? Do we protest in order to get people to look at us, to know us, to revere us, even to idolize us?

Bobby: [If] I am going to make the biggest change, I need to make sure as many people see my body and the message it carries. I have to shine a light on these words, this history. I need to step up on a larger platform.

If so, then are we actually trying to bring about the good, or is it all, as Lucy says, performance, and Haia says, just masturbation?

I call this particular stance the most audacious in Crux because you would expect a play dedicated to “those who fight” to discuss the most effective forms of rebellion and resistance, not to call into question the very basis for that rebellion and resistance. But of course Bender does because her literary career shows us she’ll always go where you might think no one would ever go. Since Bender’s obviously not interested in dismissing protest out of hand, she meditates on the role of this egocentrism. On one hand, there’s Haia’s belief that it’s all masturbatory. On the other hand, there’s the fact that in order for your rebellion to be recognized (and therefore effective), you have to be known. At a staged reading in New York City, Bender asked the audience if they’d heard of any of the revolutionaries in Crux. I admit, I didn’t know a single one:

Bobby: Sometimes, but only sometimes, deep inside my heart, I worry that this is all for nothing. That I have lost and that I will lose again all that is me and mine.

Here, it might seem like this play is a warning about the dangers of protest, that you might go through the excruciating ordeal that is starvation (like Sands), that is torture at the hands of the powers that be, and nothing will come of it, not even the legal specification that Bobby is asking for (that IRA members should be seen as political prisoners, not humdrum criminals).

Whereas that admonition most certainly appears in Crux, Bender is not encouraging would-be activists to bolster their social media followings before starting their hunger strikes. Instead, she’s up to something else. First, throughout the play a network of revolutionaries appears on a screen that no one on the stage can see. And although you may be as ignorant as your humble reviewer about the real-life backgrounds of these characters, you will certainly know many of the projected dissidents. Furthermore, Crux begins with a lecture on quantum physics by John Stewart Bell, who teaches us that subatomic particles can still affect each other even when they’re lightyears apart, even though “Einstein famously dismissed the idea of a relationship between two entities across vast unknowns as ‘spooky action at a distance.’” Finally, Sands ties it all together for us when he says to his mostly deceased friends:

Bobby: What if ghosts are less a manifestation of something past but rather an opening through time? I see you as you were, even from this distance.

In other words, every act of civil disobedience influences, in some way, another act of the same even if you, the dissident, are relatively unknown. No, it’s true, you might not be Susan B. Anthony, or Mahatma Ghandi, or Martin Luther King, Jr. But you might, in some small way, help bring about the person who will become the revolutionary who brings about real change.

I have said before that Bender has no problem looking into the darkness, has no problem presenting the darkness, and that we are better for it. But, in a play where everything seems so bleak, with our protagonist, Bobby Sands, slowly dying of starvation, with the English government unmoved to change at all (Margaret Thatcher’s “Crime is crime is crime” appearing a couple of times), Bender in her wonderfully cerebral and sublimely visceral play, delivers something so much more shocking:

Hope.

Crux, by Jesi Bender. Montclair, New Jersey: Sagging Meniscus Press, November 2026. 134 pages. $19.95, paper.

Andrew Farkas is the author of Movies Are Fine for a Bright Boy Like You, The Ancient Mysteries of Las Vegas, Are You Now or Have You Ever Been?, The Great Indoorsman: Essays, The Big Red Herring, Sunsphere, and Self-Titled Debut. He is a fiction editor for Always Crashing and Associate Professor of Creative Writing at Washburn University.

Check out HFR’s book catalog, publicity list, submission manager, and buy merch from our Spring store. Follow us on Instagram, Bluesky, and YouTube. Disclosure: HFR is an affiliate of Bookshop.org and we will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Sales from Bookshop.org help support independent bookstores and small presses.